Does Privatized Health Insurance Benefit Patients or Producers? Evidence from Medicare Advantage

October 2015
Marika Cabral, Michael Geruso, Neale Mahoney

A central question in the debate over privatized Medicare is whether increased government payments to private Medicare Advantage (MA) plans generate lower premiums for consumers or higher profits for producers. Using difference-in-differences variation brought about by a sharp legislative change, we find that MA insurers pass through 44% of increased payments in lower premiums and an additional 8% in more generous benefits. We show that advantageous selection into MA cannot explain this incomplete pass-through. Instead, our evidence suggests that market power is important, with premium pass-through rates of 13% in the least competitive markets and 74% in the most competitive.

Related People
Associated Content