We introduce a framework to evaluate the welfare effects of residential energy efficiency programs and estimate key parameters using a 100,000-household field experiment. Results generally contradict conventional wisdom: there is no evidence of informational or behavioral market failures, efficiency investments entail large non-monetary costs and benefits, and realized energy savings are just 58% of engineering predictions. The programs we study reduce social welfare by $0.18 per subsidy dollar, because investment subsidies are poorly targeted to externality damages and marginal program participants are unlikely to make externality-reducing investments. Such self-selection may undermine socially desirable program expansion in this and other domains.

More on this topic

BFI Working Paper·Nov 5, 2026

The Economics of Transitioning Away from Fossil Fuels: A Contribution to the COP30 Presidency Roadmap

Robin Burgess and Michael Greenstone
Topics: Energy & Environment
BFI Working Paper·Nov 2, 2026

Green Tastes, Beliefs, and Portfolios: Evidence from Synthetic Investors

Xindi He and Lubos Pastor
Topics: Energy & Environment, Financial Markets
BFI Working Paper·Oct 21, 2026

Green Subsidies with Demand Distortions

Susanna B. Berkouwer and Joshua Dean
Topics: Energy & Environment