Do early investments in parents pay off even when treatment effects for children appear to fade out quickly? We answer this question by leveraging a field experiment in which households with 3-5 year-old children were randomized into a parenting program, a preschool, or a control group, combined with a natural experiment (Covid-19 school closures) that occurred ten years later. Prior to the closures, treatment effects on academic achievement had faded to zero across all groups. Yet, with Covid-19 school closures, effects of the parenting program re-emerge: test scores in control and preschool groups drop by roughly 0.25-0.30 SD, whereas scores in the parenting group drop by only 0.11 SD (difference: p = 0.01). Our findings suggest that parenting programs can generate latent human capital that only becomes visible when complementary school inputs are removed. This result is consonant with parental and school investments acting as substitutes in skill production. Because this latent parental capacity pays off precisely when school inputs fail, standard measurement tools for early childhood programs can miss crucial state-contingent value.

More on this topic

BFI Working Paper·Aug 14, 2026

A Novel Assessment of Epistemic Curiosity and its Association With Early Learning Outcomes

Ariel Kalil, Mauricio Koechlin, Dana McCoy, Michelle Michelini, and Terri Sabol
Topics: Early Childhood Education
BFI Working Paper·Jul 27, 2026

Relating Cognitive Skills and Personality Traits to Economic Preferences: Decision-Making under Cognitive Shocks and Guessing

Cesar Chavez Padilla, Shuaizhang Feng, James Heckman, and Zhe Yang
Topics: K-12 Education
BFI Working Paper·Jun 15, 2026

AI Diffusion Gaps: Unequal Integration of AI Across K-12 Schools

Christopher Campos and John Singleton
Topics: K-12 Education