Governments and firms often employ soft spending limits to restrict overspending while still allowing exceptions on a case-by-case basis. This paper studies a Medicare policy which capped per-patient physical therapy spending, with exceptions for patients with documented medical need. The cap reduced spending by 8 percent without harming patient health, with the targeting improvements driven by Medicare discretion in granting exceptions rather than improved provider screening. However, the documentation requirement also introduced horizontal inequity: conditional on need, lower-income and minority patients were more likely to be screened out, as they tended to see providers with poorer documentation practices.

More on this topic

BFI Working Paper·May 13, 2025

Saved by Medicaid: New Evidence on Health Insurance and Mortality from the Universe of Low-Income Adults

Angela Wyse and Bruce Meyer
Topics: Health care, Tax & Budget
BFI Working Paper·Apr 23, 2025

Evaluating Recent Crackdowns on Disability Benefits: Effects on Income and Health Care Use in Australia

Manasi Deshpande, Greg Kaplan, and Tobias Leigh-Wood
Topics: Employment & Wages, Health care
BFI Working Paper·Apr 7, 2025

Mechanism Design for Personalized Policy: A Field Experiment Incentivizing Exercise

Rebecca Dizon-Ross and Ariel D. Zucker
Topics: Health care