This paper examines the economic foundations of three criteria used for evaluating the costs and benefits of social programs. Some criteria do not consider the scale of programs or address the costs associated with programs that expand or contract the total government budget. A recent addition to the list of evaluation criteria—the marginal value of public funds (MVPF)—does not adopt a social optimality perspective. It evaluates the optimality of expenditures assuming a predetermined aggregate budget without considering the social costs of raising that budget.

More on this topic

BFI Working Paper·Nov 16, 2026

The Role of Parental Beliefs and Public Policies in Financing Higher Education: An Experimental Study

Francesco Agostinelli, Guglielmo Briscese, and Giovanni M. Topa
Topics: Economic Mobility & Poverty, Higher Education & Workforce Training
BFI Working Paper·Nov 10, 2026

When Food Stamps Became Free: Impacts and Implications of Removing the Purchase Requirement

Amy Finkelstein, Matthew Notowidigdo, and Charlie Rafkin
Topics: Economic Mobility & Poverty
BFI Working Paper·Oct 21, 2026

What Can (and Cannot) Be Learned about Systemic Racial Discrimination from Randomized Controlled Trials?

Dania V. Francis, Rob Gillezeau, Damon Jones, and Angelino C. G. Viceisza
Topics: Economic Mobility & Poverty