Research / BFI Working PaperJul 16, 2020

Inference with Imperfect Randomization: The Case of the Perry Preschool Program

James Heckman, Rodrigo Pinto, Azeem Shaikh

This paper considers the problem of making inferences about the effects of a program on multiple out-comes when the assignment of treatment status is imperfectly randomized. By imperfect randomization we mean that treatment status is reassigned after an initial randomization on the basis of characteristics that may be observed or unobserved by the analyst. We develop a partial identification approach to this problem that makes use of information limiting the extent to which randomization is imperfect to show that it is still possible to make nontrivial inferences about the effects of the program in such settings. We consider a family of null hypotheses in which each null hypothesis specifies that the program has no effect on one of several outcomes of interest. Under weak assumptions, we construct a procedure for testing this family of null hypotheses in a way that controls the familywise error rate – the probability of even one false rejection – in finite samples. We develop our methodology in the context of a reanalysis of the HighScope Perry Preschool program. We find statistically significant effects of the program on a number of different outcomes of interest, including outcomes related to criminal activity for males and females, even after accounting for the imperfectness of the randomization and the multiplicity of null hypotheses.

More Research From These Scholars

BFI Working Paper Dec 22, 2019

Randomization Tests in Observational Studies with Staggered Adoption of Treatment

Azeem Shaikh, Panos Toulis
Topics:  Uncategorized
BFI Working Paper Oct 4, 2022

Three Criteria for Evaluating Social Programs

James Heckman, Jorge Luis García
Topics:  Economic Mobility & Poverty
BFI Working Paper Feb 13, 2023

Covariate Adjustment in Experiments with Matched Pairs

Yuehao Bai, Liang Jiang, Joseph P. Romano, Azeem Shaikh, Yichong Zhang
Topics:  Uncategorized